Fact: Police are Much More Likely to Shoot the Wrong Person than Armed Citizens

Published by the LearnAboutGuns.com Author on February 17, 2009 at 12:22 am
LearnAboutGuns.com > Pro Gun Rights Articles > Fact: Police are Much More Likely to Shoot the Wrong Person than Armed Citizens

One of the recurring anti gun arguments that I hear centers on the mistaken belief that gun owners will end up shooting an innocent person (such as a child, bystander, etc.) when trying to defend themselves against a criminal.  The fact is that armed citizens are about 5.5 times less likely than the police to accidentally shoot the wrong person.

[A]lthough only 2 percent of those involved in civilian shootings are misidentified, 11 percent of individuals involved in police shootings were later found to be innocents misidentified as criminals.

There could be several reasons why this is the case.  First, it could be that the police are more willing to use force, as police officers who use force tend to run less of a risk of facing criminal charges than ordinary citizens who use force.  Secondly, it could be that police are called into a situation where they don’t know the people in the home and therefore are not as able to identify who is a “good guy” and who is a “bad guy.”   Thirdly, it could be that police have less of a personal stake in the outcome of the shooting, while a person whose children could be in the home would seem to have a stronger interest in making sure they don’t unintentionally shoot their own child [note: I’m not saying police would like to shoot a person’s child, but that a child’s mother or father almost always love that child more than a cop who has never before met the child]. Regardless of the underlying reason, the fact remains that when an ordinary citizen draws his or her gun, he or she is much less likely to shoot an innocent person than when a cop draws his or her gun.

ALSO READ:  An Often Overlooked Benefit of Armed Citizens Stopping Crime

Stories in the news abound with cases of cops shooting the wrong person, be it a woman who is cooperating, an innocent bystander who is not involved at all, a suspect who is face down, or just someone whose skin is the wrong color.  The fact is that while police serve an important role in society, interactions with them can be dangerous, even for law abiding citizens.  That is why while I hope to never have to fire a gun in self defense, I would much rather shoot in self defense than have armed police officers open fire in my vicinity, even if they are trying their best to stop a criminal.

Unarmed Self Defense and Disaster Preparedness e-books:

Tags for this article: , , , , ,

  • Dale

    The NCPA link in this article doesn't work any more. Can you find a new link? I tried but don't know exactly what to look for in their site.

  • Fabian

    Same question as Dale, since it seems his has gone under without being adressed. I would like to be able to quote this with a source, so I was disappointed to find the one you used wasn’t available anymore.

  • https://www.learnaboutguns.com The LearnAboutGuns.com Author

    Dale, Fabian:

    Here is a link from Archive.org, which keeps copies of
    webpages as they existed in the past: http://web.archive.org/web/20060110172000/http://www.ncpa.org/pub/st/st176/s176d.html

  • Fabian

    Thank you for the prompt response!

  • http://www.pepe.com Alt Fight

    how come David Hogg wasn’t there to whore himself to the media?

  • henrybowmanaz

    Apparently the National Center for Policy Analysis relinquished ncpa.org, which was picked up by the National Community Pharmacists Association, which is why the link goes nowhere. Thanks for the archive.org version, which works fine.